Halloween teaches kids some important life lessons: talk to your neighbors, say thank you, and immediately identify which houses are handing out Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups.
Because all Halloween candy is not created equal.
Some candy makes you feel like you hit the jackpot. Some becomes valuable currency during the living-room candy trade. And some sits at the bottom of the bag until somebody finally throws it away around Thanksgiving.
Then there’s candy corn, which somehow returns every October despite everything we know about it.
Here’s our ranking of the best Halloween candy, starting with the obvious winner and ending with the tiny traffic cones of disappointment.
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups: The Best Halloween Candy
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups are the best Halloween candy. There. We can all stop pretending this requires a committee.
Chocolate and peanut butter belong together. The chocolate gives you sweetness, the peanut butter brings a little salt, and the combination makes most other candy feel like it needs to explain itself.
A Reese’s in your trick-or-treat bag was a win. Two meant the evening was going well. A full-size package meant that house immediately earned a permanent place on next year’s route.
And Reese’s pumpkins? Also excellent. You can debate the ideal chocolate-to-peanut-butter ratio while I eat another one.
The verdict: First pick from the bowl. Highest priority in the candy trade. Undisputed champion.
Snickers: The Candy Bar That Shows Up Ready
Snickers brings chocolate, caramel, peanuts, and nougat. That’s a lot happening in one wrapper, and somehow everybody does their job.
It has crunch. It has chew. It feels substantial enough that you can almost convince yourself you made a responsible snack decision.
You didn’t. But Halloween isn’t an audit.
The verdict: A dependable heavyweight that deserves better than being left in the office candy bowl.
Kit Kat: Four Little Reasons to Be Happy
Kit Kat understands something important: texture matters.
The chocolate and crispy wafer combination delivers without getting complicated. You can break it into neat pieces like a civilized person or bite straight across the whole thing and make everyone nearby uncomfortable.
Either way, it works.
The verdict: A top-tier Halloween candy with the added benefit of giving opinionated people another thing to argue about.
Twix: An Excellent Use of Caramel
Twix combines a cookie, caramel, and chocolate. That’s a strong application.
The cookie gives it enough crunch to stand out, while the caramel makes a fun-size bar disappear considerably faster than you intended.
The only real problem with a small Twix is that you immediately want another Twix.
The verdict: A reliable first-round candy pick.
Peanut M&M’s: Better With a Little Crunch
Regular M&M’s are good. Peanut M&M’s take the same idea and give it something extra.
They’re crunchy, chocolatey, and easy to eat by the handful while “checking” the candy your kids brought home.
At a certain point, that inspection becomes theft. Most parents seem comfortable with the distinction.
The verdict: Excellent bowl candy. Dangerous open-bag candy.
Skittles: The Best Break From Chocolate
A Halloween candy ranking needs something for the fruity-candy crowd, and Skittles earns the spot.
After several rounds of chocolate, caramel, and peanut butter, a little chewy fruit flavor makes sense. Skittles also has the advantage of being easy to trade because practically everyone has a favorite color.
Someone will insist all the colors taste the same. That person can receive an empty bag.
The verdict: A strong change of pace in a chocolate-heavy lineup.
Starburst: Good Candy, Excessive Paperwork
Starburst tastes good. Getting into it feels like processing tiny documents.
First comes the outer wrapper. Then each individual piece has its own wrapper. By the time you finish a handful, your coffee table looks like a shipping department.
Still, the chewy fruit flavors earn their place.
The verdict: Worth eating. Could streamline the onboarding process.
Last Place: Candy Corn, the Worst Halloween Candy
Candy corn looks exactly like Halloween.
Unfortunately, it also tastes like someone described frosting to a candle manufacturer.
It’s aggressively sweet, has a texture that raises questions, and inspires an annual defense from people who say, “It’s actually good mixed with peanuts.”
So we need to bring in another food to fix it? That feels relevant.
Candy corn is a perfectly acceptable decoration. Put it in a glass jar. Scatter it around a centerpiece. Let it contribute visually.
But if I reach into a Halloween candy bowl and pull out candy corn while Reese’s is available, something has gone terribly wrong.
The verdict: Outstanding seasonal branding. Last place as a snack.
What Makes the Best Halloween Candy?
The best Halloween candy is the stuff you’re excited to find in the bag.
It’s what you save for later—or eat immediately because you don’t trust the people you live with. It’s the candy you remember getting from that one house that always handed out the good stuff.
For us, that’s Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. Chocolate, peanut butter, and no need to mix in anything else to make them enjoyable.
Candy corn can have the centerpiece.
Be the first to comment