Imagine watching baseball on August 11 with absolutely no idea that you had just watched the final games of the season.
No pennant races in September.
No playoffs.
No World Series.
No champion.
That sounds almost impossible now, but that’s exactly what happened because of the 1994 baseball strike.
On August 12, 1994, Major League Baseball players went on strike. What initially looked like another ugly labor dispute eventually became something much bigger: the first canceled World Series in 90 years.
And 32 years later, the craziest part isn’t simply that baseball stopped.
It’s what was happening when it stopped.
Tony Gwynn was flirting with .400.
Matt Williams was chasing Roger Maris.
And the Montreal Expos — yes, the Montreal Expos — had the best record in baseball.
Then everybody went home.
Baseball Was Having a Fascinating Season
It’s easy to remember 1994 simply as “the strike year.”
That’s selling the season short.
Baseball had already played more than 100 games, and several potentially historic stories were developing.
Then August 12 arrived.
The players walked out, and what would become a 232-day strike began. The remaining regular-season schedule was eventually canceled along with the postseason and World Series.
There would be no 1994 champion.
But there also would be no answers to three questions baseball fans can still argue about today.
What If Tony Gwynn Had Hit .400?
This might be the most painful one.
Tony Gwynn entered the strike batting:
.394.
Not .364.
Not .374.
.394.
Gwynn had 165 hits in 419 at-bats and had been particularly hot heading into the stoppage.
Ted Williams had become the last major leaguer to hit .400 when he batted .406 in 1941.
More than half a century later, Gwynn had a legitimate chance to join him.
And Gwynn wasn’t some random player having a fluky four-month stretch.
This was Tony Gwynn.
One of the greatest pure hitters who ever lived.
He would finish his career with a .338 batting average and eight National League batting titles. His .394 in 1994 remains the highest season batting average since Williams’ .406.
Would Gwynn actually have gotten there?
We’ll never know.
Maybe the pressure of September would have gotten to him. Maybe a cold streak would have dropped him into the .380s.
Or maybe Tony Gwynn would have done what Tony Gwynn did better than almost anyone who ever picked up a bat:
Hit baseballs where fielders weren’t standing.
The maddening part is that he got close enough to make the question legitimate.
What If Matt Williams Had Broken Roger Maris’ Record?
Here’s another number that doesn’t look real:
43 home runs in 112 games.
That’s how many Matt Williams had hit for the San Francisco Giants when the season ended.
At the time, Roger Maris’ 61 home runs in 1961 remained the most famous single-season power record in baseball.
Williams was on pace to challenge it.
A straight 162-game projection puts 43 homers through 112 games at a pace of roughly 62 home runs.
Think about what that could have meant.
Four years later, Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa captivated America by chasing Maris. McGwire eventually hit 70 and Sosa 66.
But what if Williams had gotten to 62 first?
The entire mythology surrounding the summer of 1998 might look a little different.
Instead, Williams’ final line forever reads:
112 games. 43 home runs.
We’ll never know what the next 50 games might have produced.
And Then There Are the Montreal Expos
This may be the biggest what-if of all.
When baseball stopped, Montreal was 74–40.
Not just first in the NL East.
The Expos had the best record in Major League Baseball.
They were six games ahead of the Atlanta Braves and had won 20 more games than they’d lost on the road.
This wasn’t a cute underdog hanging around in August.
Montreal was a legitimate World Series contender.
The roster included names like Larry Walker, Moisés Alou, Marquis Grissom and Pedro Martínez. MLB itself has described the 1994 Expos as one of baseball’s great historical what-ifs.
Then the strike hit.
There was no postseason.
There was no chance for Montreal to find out how good it really was.
And what happened afterward makes the story hurt even more.
The economics surrounding the franchise changed. Key players departed. The Expos never again reached those heights.
Ten years later, the franchise left Montreal and eventually became the Washington Nationals.
Which creates one of baseball’s greatest alternate-history questions:
What happens if the Montreal Expos win the 1994 World Series?
Does a championship create a new generation of Expos fans?
Does attendance explode?
Does the organization find a way to keep more of its talent?
Does Montreal eventually get a new stadium?
Most importantly:
Are the Expos still playing in Montreal today?
There’s no way to know.
But it’s hard not to wonder.
One Strike Left Us With Three Great Baseball Mysteries
That’s what makes the 1994 season different from an ordinary canceled or shortened season.
It didn’t end before anything interesting happened.
It ended right in the middle of the interesting part.
Tony Gwynn was hitting .394.
Matt Williams had 43 home runs.
Montreal was 74–40.
Fans weren’t looking back at projections before Opening Day and wondering what might have happened.
They had already watched these stories develop for four months.
And then…
baseball just stopped.
No ending.
No September collapse.
No magical postseason run.
No heartbreaking Game 7.
Nothing.
Thirty-two years later, we’re still left with three questions baseball can never answer:
Would Tony Gwynn have hit .400?
Would Matt Williams have broken Roger Maris’ home-run record?
And could a World Series championship have saved Major League Baseball in Montreal?
Every baseball fan probably has a different answer.
That’s part of what makes 1994 one of the strangest seasons in sports history.
It isn’t remembered for how it ended.
It’s remembered because it never got the chance to.
Be the first to comment